Per multiple sources (NBC, for instance), the Giants made the following roster moves before the Rule 5 draft:
- DFA IF Christian Koss
- DFA RHP Rowan Wick
- Added LHP Henry Lalane
- Added RHP Marty Gair
- Added RHP Josh Bostick
As reported before today, the Giants traded Ryan Walker to the Brewers for RHP Blake Holub and RHP Gavin Perry, which cleared a 40-man roster spot.
ogc thoughts
As expected, the Giants protected Lalane and Gair, two of the players picked up in trades at the trade deadline in 2026 season.
Henry Lalane (#11) is only 23 YO next season and expected to pitch in AA in 2027 (though, because he’s now on the 40, he won’t be allowed to until the new CBA is signed). He has a plus fastball and changeup, and might have more in the tank for upside because he only started pitching at age 14. He had shoulder problems which appear to have fixed his issues, as his velocity ticked upward in 2026, perhaps now that his shoulder is healed, perhaps because of his learning curve. And his control is a lot better, his walk rate is good, around 3 BB/9, whereas before he was very wild.
On a side note, it could be a good rotation at Richmond with the pitchers expected to be assigned there. Along with Lalane, many media outlets have listed Jacob Bresnahan (#9), Jackson Flora (#3), and Ramon Marquez (#5), who are the three top pitching prospects (Bolemon, a high schooler, is ranked fourth among prospects, FYI). However, since he will now be locked out, any of them could push their way to AAA by the time he’s allowed to rejoin the team.
Marty Gair (unranked) is reported to have a 100 MPH fastball, and Posey said that he wanted more stuff from his pitchers. Showing this, he had 84 strikeouts in 48 IP in 2026, and reached AA. With Doval and Rodriguez coming back, and Gair perhaps reaching the majors at some point, the Giants bullpen could have a lot of high velocity pitchers by the end of the season, especially if they decide to promote Miguel Mendez (#16), who is doing great in the Arizona Fall League, showing near 100 MPH heat.
Also protected is Josh Bostick. Per NBC, he missed all of 2026 due to a torn Achilles. He was drafted in 2023, and had a 3.71 ERA in Eugene in 2025. He was ranked #19 Giants prospect in 2025, before his injury and surgery. He had a mid-90’s fastball, sometimes reaching 100, before his injury, which was rated a 60 on the scouting scale, and he also had an above average slider. He appears to be the Spencer Miles of this season, who might get selected in Rule 5 and then do well for his new team. But that’s no guarantee that he’s any good, every prospect is different, only the circumstances are similar.
Clearing 40-Man Space
The flip side of protecting prospects is that space has to be opened up on the 40-man. Trading Ryan Walker, who likely would have been DFAed, got the Giants Holub and Perry in return, and opened up a 40-man spot.
However, Holub is also a Rule 5 eligible player, so the teams traded players they were not planning on protecting. Brewers got a pitcher they consider better having, probably since he had MLB success before and maybe they can fix him, and the Giants at minimum got a draft pick in Perry, in exchange for a player they were releasing, plus maybe keep Holub, who is already 28 YO and just had his first good (but not great) AAA season, if he isn’t drafted in the Rule 5 draft (again, it is unknown if the draft happens, but last time, that lockout canceled the draft).
They also DFAed Koss and Wick to get two more spots. Wick wasn’t highly sought after (they signed him to a $600K deal for 2027), especially at 34 YO and recovering from injury, so I assume that they expect to resign him after he passes through waivers.
Koss created very good value (average WAR) in 2025, but most of it was because 1) he hit nearly MLB average, while 2) playing great defense at 2B. Unfortunately, in 2026, he hit a lot worse and he rarely played 2B, mostly SS and 3B, where he wasn’t as elite defensively as he was at 2B. He was the quintessential replacement level player in 2026, and this is probably why he was let go.
And he was not likely to get to play much at 2B in 2027 with Mayer and Schmitt around. They will likely get the vast majority of starts there. And as Andy Baggarly noted in his article (The Athletic subscription required), Gavin Kilen played well in AA and could be pushing for the majors by midseason. Plus he’ll be 29 YO, and given his great 2B defense in 2025, likely will find another team with 2B open, and where he can be a MI/IF bench player.
On top of that, Jhonny Level did well at both levels of A-ball at only 19 YO. He’s likely to be placed in AA for 2027 (Kilen AAA, Josuar Gonzalez Advanced A, Luis Hernandez A, Joniel Hernandez Rookie League). He has hit well at every level, and if he continues in 2027, he could also be pushing for the majors by midseason.
Rule 5 Eligible Notes
As mentioned, the Rule 5 Draft might not even happen, but the Giants protected the players just in case. And Holub is one of the prospects now exposed. Others unprotected include interesting prospects like LHP Joe Whitman (#23), LHP Luis De La Torre (#25), and C Jancel Villarroel (#18).
Have liked Whitman for a while now, and he had a good 2026 season, but not great, as he dominated in AA but was good but not outstanding in AAA. I was worried that he might be exposed, as he is only 25 YO next year, and has done well rising up the farm system.
The other two I haven’t followed much. De La Torre was a prospect mentioned a lot in the 2026 preseason by analysts I read, because of his great 2025 season, but had a very disappointing season, with a 5.81 ERA in only Advanced A ball. He has near 100 MPH velocity, so that would be attractive to other teams, especially in relief, but he walked over 7 BB/9, which should scare other teams away, since they would need to hold him all season to keep him.
Villarroel I had hardly ever seen any prospect coverage. I assume that’s why he was not protected. He’s nominally a catcher, but has played across the diamond at most other positions, so his value is really because of this flexibility. He has a good season in Advanced A, but struggled greatly in AA, so I can’t imagine that any team would be interested in keeping him on the 25-man roster all season. He’s only 22 YO next season, and catching slows the development of prospects, so he should still have some potential, and hence why he’s ranked 18th.
No comments:
Post a Comment