Just some reactions to what I read in the newspaper:
A's Bias
The columnist I wrote about the other day beats up on the Giants about their offense, and yet I have not seen one column about what the A's were thinking nor about how poorly they have played so far. What made them think that their starting rotation was ready for the big time after going out and getting Matt Holliday, Jason Giambi, and Orlando Cabrera to boost the offense? And not that I regret it, because then the Giants ended up with him, but they really could have used a starter like Randy Johnson, who is also an East Bay native and a natural attraction since he's going to win 300 games, plus, more importantly, could have been the ace of the staff for them, or at worse #2 to maybe Duchscherer. They chose not to do that.
The A's right now, even with all the big batters they added, which, by the way, pushed top prospect Daric Barton to the minors, are averaging under 4 runs per game. Where is the vitriol for their lousy offensive performance, particularly since they went out and got Matt Holliday and Giambi? Why no nasty column? I mean, the Giants we already know will have a bad offense, picking on them when they are struggling is, well, beating a dead horse, we all knew that already, what's the big deal?
However, the A's made the huge blockbuster trade for Holliday and the nostalgic signing of Giambi to boost the offense, and neither has a homerun yet. In fact, the Giants have been pounded about their lack of offense and homers, but they currently have more than double the homers that the A's have, and they have scored about the same number of runs, 50 for the A's, 45 for the Giants: both poor, but that was expected for the Giants, not so much for the A's given their upgrades on offense.
And, despite the great ERA overall for the pitching staff, their K/9, BB/9 and K/BB are horrible, and if that continued, their ERA should soar much higher. So why not talk about how badly they are doing in those departments, particularly walks, which is over 4 walks per 9 IP. I know that this is being hammered on the Giants in their coverage, yet I don't see that at all for the A's. The A's starter walked 4 batters last night, and all that was noted was that he did that, nothing about the high number of walks, nothing about the lack of strikeouts (which I've been hammering on about how the Giants have been building right).
Walk-Aversion Has its Limits
Speaking of walks, it was noted by one writer that because Cain had a walk-free outing, he "never allowed any jams to turn into big innings." And on the surface, that makes a lot of sense, "no walks good, lots of walks bad". However, he failed to note that Cain gave up 9 hits in his 6 innings too. That's not good either, as hits are worse than walks for creating runs.
And I understand that the pitcher has minimal control over the number of hits he gives up, as espoused by DIPS theory, but he does have some control and that is via strikeouts. Cain in his first full season struck out batters at a 8.4 K/9 rate, helping him to a low 7.4 H/9. But his K/9 has dipped from that high to 7.3, 7.7 and only 6.2 so far this season (albeit small sampling). He has likewise reduced his walks as well, at about the same rate, so that his K/BB rate has been remarkably steady, 2.06, 2.06, 2.04, 2.17.
So what is the overall result from his trying to reduce his walks, which has been high? His WHIP has increased from 1.28 to 1.26 to 1.364 to 1.368. And if he has been allowing more baserunners (per his WHIP) while reducing walks, that means he's been giving up a lot more hits. And hits hurt you more than walks.
The good news about this year is that his BABIP is abnormally high, at .328, and reducing it to .300 would return his H/9 back to last year's 8.5, resulting in a reduced WHIP back to his 1.26 of previous years, assuming he can keep his BB/9 down below 3 (currently 2.8 BB/9).
Thus, as good as he has been the past two years, he could be, at age 24, be taking the next step in his development, much like Lincecum did last year when he turned 24, towards becoming a complete pitcher. Getting his walk rate down has been his big need as a starter, and he has made progress, but this is his first time with his walk rate below 3.0 after 3 starts in the season and thus astonishingly the latest it has been that low, and amazingly enough, this is already his 4th season starting off the season with the Giants. And he was already very good the last two seasons, with ERA in the mid-3's for the most part (3.64 and 3.76), so if he is able to keep his walk rate down, while keeping his strikeout at or above where it is now, we could see Cain leaping to being considered for the Cy Young this season, with a low to mid 3 ERA.
Other Giants News
* Hinshaw down, Holm up, but Sandoval starting at catcher today. Is it a coincidence that Zito is starting today? Last season, hitters in 5 games hit only .213/.293/.311/.604 with Sandoval starting at catcher, .273/.368/.414/.782 with Molina starting 22 games (much worse with Holm catching). Then again, Sandoval caught Zito when Zito was going good at the end of the season, I wonder how well hitters hit with Molina catching for those games at the end of the season too.
* Rotation will be shifted, skipping Sanchez. Some are outraged, but he's the 5th starter, and while he did pitch really well in his last outing, it makes a lot of sense, as that does two important things: now the D-backs face Lincecum, Johnson, Cain, and Cain is better than Sanchez, plus it puts the rotation to Zito, Sanchez, Lincecum against the D-gers, whereas before it would have been Cain, Zito, Sanchez. Nothing against Cain, but I would rather have Lincecum facing them than Cain. That also moves Lincecum from facing D-Rox to facing the D-gers, which is more important as the D-Rox are struggling too, so now they face Johnson, Cain, Zito.
Then we're on the road for a week, Sanchez/Lincecum against the Cubs, Johnson/Cain against D-Rox, and Zito/Sanchez/Lincecum against the D-gers. Thus the move allows Lincecum to face the D-gers twice, instead of them avoiding him twice. I think that is a Win/Win situation, putting our best pitcher against the top team in our division, instead of missing them twice.
However, I wonder how long the drop to 11 man pitching staff will last because Friday May 1st will be the start of 17 days of playing games without a break. I would expect somebody to be dropped to the minors, probably between Velez and Torres, before the start of the road trip that begins on May 4th. And they only have two days off the whole month of May.
These are just my opinions. I cannot promise that I will be perfect, but I can promise that I will seek to understand and illuminate whatever moves that the Giants make (my obsession and compulsion). I will share my love of baseball and my passion for the Giants. And I will try to teach, best that I can. Often, I tackle the prevailing mood among Giants fans and see if that is a correct stance, good or bad.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
1984 Draft
(1)
2007 Draft
(15)
2007 Giants
(52)
2008 Draft
(22)
2008 Giants
(53)
2008 season
(6)
2009 Draft
(18)
2009 Giants
(87)
2009 season
(24)
2010 Decade
(12)
2010 Draft
(11)
2010 Giants
(137)
2010 NL ROY award
(1)
2010 season
(19)
2010's
(3)
2011 Draft
(9)
2011 Giants
(84)
2011 season
(8)
2012 Draft
(11)
2012 Giants
(93)
2012 season
(11)
2013 Draft
(3)
2013 Giants
(39)
2013 season
(5)
2014
(1)
2014 draft
(5)
2014 Giants
(79)
2014 season
(16)
2015 Draft
(4)
2015 Giants
(50)
2015 season
(10)
2016 Draft
(1)
2016 Giants
(45)
2016 season
(6)
2017 Draft
(3)
2017 Giants
(27)
2018 Draft
(8)
2018 Giants
(50)
2018 Season
(8)
2019 Draft
(1)
2019 Giants
(27)
2019 season
(2)
2020 Decade
(1)
2020 Giants
(9)
20201 Draft
(1)
2021 Giants
(3)
2022 Giants
(2)
2023 Giants
(14)
2023 season
(1)
2024 Giants
(18)
2025 Giants
(1)
25 man roster
(11)
25th man fallacy
(1)
26 man roster
(1)
3B
(1)
40 Man Roster
(11)
49ers
(1)
5-day rotation
(1)
51/49 decisions
(1)
6-man rotation
(5)
89 Quake
(1)
89 World Series
(1)
A-Ball
(1)
A-Gon
(1)
A-Rod
(3)
A's
(6)
AA-Ball
(1)
Aaron Rowand
(25)
Abiatal Avelino
(1)
accomplishments
(1)
ace pitcher
(2)
ace starter
(4)
Adalberto Mejia
(6)
Adam Duvall
(5)
AFL
(4)
aggression
(1)
AL Playoffs
(1)
Albert Suarez
(5)
Alen Hanson
(3)
Alex Cobb
(1)
Alex Dickerson
(2)
Alex Hinshaw
(3)
Alex Pavlovic
(1)
Alexander Canario
(2)
All-Star Game
(1)
almost perfect game
(1)
Alonzo Powell
(1)
Amphetamine
(3)
analysis
(24)
Andre Torres
(14)
Andres Torres
(2)
Andrew Baiiley
(1)
Andrew Bailey
(1)
Andrew McCutchen
(2)
Andrew Suarez
(5)
Andrew Susac
(11)
Andy Baggerly
(2)
Andy Sisco
(1)
Andy Suarez
(9)
Angel Joseph
(1)
Angel Pagan
(17)
Angel Villalona
(30)
Anniversary
(1)
appendicitis
(1)
Aramis Garcia
(2)
Arbitration
(19)
Armando Benitez
(5)
Armando Gallaraga
(1)
art of failure
(1)
Asia-Pacific signing
(1)
assessment
(1)
Astros
(3)
At the Rate They Are Going
(1)
ATT Park
(1)
Aubrey Huff
(20)
Austin Jackson
(2)
Austin Slater
(5)
Award
(4)
BABIP
(3)
Bam Bam Meulens
(1)
Barry Bonds
(30)
Barry Zito
(77)
baseball
(1)
Baseball America
(3)
Baseball Prospectus
(6)
Baseball Prospectus Bias Against Giants
(4)
baseball strategy
(9)
Baseball Study
(18)
baserunning
(2)
batting peripherals
(1)
batting stance analysis
(1)
batting title champion
(1)
Beat LA
(9)
bench players
(4)
Bengie Molina
(14)
Benjamin Snyder
(1)
Bert Blyleven
(1)
best manager
(2)
best practices
(2)
Beyond the Box Score
(1)
Bias Against Giants
(1)
Big 6
(9)
Big Picture
(3)
Bill Hall
(1)
Bill James
(1)
Bill James Handbook
(2)
Bill Mueller
(1)
Bill Neukom
(21)
Billy Beane
(3)
biography
(1)
Blake Riverra
(1)
Blake Snell
(1)
blog news
(3)
Blog Philosophy
(3)
Bob Howry
(2)
Bob Mariano
(1)
Bobby Evans
(4)
Boston Red Sox
(1)
Brad Hennessey
(5)
Brad Penny
(2)
Brandon Bednar
(1)
Brandon Belt
(50)
Brandon Crawford
(25)
Brandon Hicks
(1)
Braves
(5)
breakout
(2)
Brett Bochy
(4)
Brett Pill
(9)
Brewers
(1)
Brian Anderson
(1)
Brian Bannister
(3)
Brian Bocock
(2)
Brian Cooper
(1)
Brian Horwitz
(3)
Brian Ragira
(2)
Brian Sabean
(50)
Brian Wilson
(14)
Bridegrooms
(6)
Bruce Bochy
(36)
Bryce Eldridge
(2)
Bucky Showalter
(1)
bulllpen
(8)
Bullpen
(33)
Business Plan
(23)
Buster Posey
(103)
Byran Reynolds
(2)
Byung-Hyun Kim
(1)
Cained
(4)
call-ups
(3)
Candlestick Park
(1)
Cards
(13)
Career Prospects
(4)
Carl Hubbell
(1)
Carlos Beltran
(4)
Carlos Gomez
(1)
Carney Lansford
(2)
Carson Whisenhunt
(2)
Carter Jurica
(1)
Casey Kelly
(1)
Casey McGeHee
(3)
catcher injury
(5)
catching
(3)
CBT penalty
(1)
CC Sabathia
(1)
censorship
(2)
CEO
(2)
Chad Gaudin
(5)
Charles Culberson
(5)
Charlie Culberson
(3)
Chase Johnson
(3)
cheating
(1)
Chillax
(1)
Chris Brown
(1)
Chris Gloor
(1)
Chris Heston
(19)
Chris Lincecum
(1)
Chris Marrero
(1)
Chris O'Leary
(1)
Chris Ray
(4)
Chris Shaw
(4)
Chris Stewart
(4)
Chris Stratton
(30)
Chris Strattton
(1)
Christian Arroyo
(7)
Christmas
(1)
Christopher Dominguez
(4)
Christy Mathewson
(1)
Chuckie Jones
(2)
Clay Hensley
(3)
Clayton Blackburn
(10)
Clayton Tanner
(3)
Closer
(9)
closer by committee
(3)
Coaches
(4)
coaching changes
(1)
Cody Hall
(2)
Cody Ross
(8)
Col
(1)
Comeback Award
(1)
Commissioner
(1)
comparison
(3)
competitive advantage
(1)
Competitive Balance Tax
(2)
Competitive Cycles
(2)
competitiveness
(2)
Conner Menez
(1)
Connor Joe
(3)
Connor Nurse
(1)
Conor Gillaspie
(25)
contender
(1)
contract extension
(3)
contract negotiations
(2)
contract signing
(7)
Coordinator
(1)
core competency
(1)
Core Rotation
(1)
Cory Gearrin
(5)
Cory Guerrin
(1)
Cory Hart
(1)
Craig Whitaker
(2)
Cubs
(1)
Curt Young
(1)
cuts
(1)
Cy Young Award
(5)
cyber-relief
(1)
D-backs
(16)
D-gers
(36)
D-Rocks
(3)
D-Rox
(17)
D.J. Snelten
(3)
Dallas McPherson
(1)
Dan Ortmeier
(11)
Dan Otero
(2)
Dan Runzler
(6)
Dan Slania
(3)
Dan Uggla
(1)
Daniel Carbonell
(1)
Daniel Slania
(2)
Dany Jimenez
(1)
Darren Ford
(1)
Dave Righetti
(1)
Dave Roberts
(11)
David Aardsma
(1)
David Bell
(1)
David Huff
(2)
David Loewenstein
(1)
Decade of the Giants
(12)
decline
(1)
Defense
(11)
Deferred Money
(1)
deleted comment
(1)
Denard Span
(3)
depth
(1)
Dereck Rodriquez
(7)
Derek Holland
(18)
Derek Law
(11)
Detroit Tigers
(1)
DFA
(3)
DH
(2)
Dick Tidrow
(2)
dictionary
(1)
direction
(1)
Dirty
(1)
DL
(3)
dodgers
(15)
Donald Snelten
(1)
Donovan Solano
(1)
Draft
(11)
Draft Analysis
(28)
Draft Bonus
(7)
draft list
(3)
draft philosophy
(2)
draft signing
(3)
Draft Strategy
(12)
Draft Study
(9)
Draft Success
(4)
drafting
(5)
Dres
(16)
Drew Pomeranz
(1)
DRS
(1)
Dynasty
(3)
Earl Weaver
(1)
Edgar Renteria
(13)
Eduardo Nunez
(4)
Edwin Escobar
(5)
Ehire Adrianza
(26)
Eli Whiteside
(4)
Elimination game
(1)
EME
(2)
Emmanuel Burriss
(18)
end of an era
(1)
epic season
(6)
era
(1)
Eric Byrnes
(1)
Eric Surkamp
(6)
Erik Cordier
(1)
Eugenio Velez
(12)
evaluation
(3)
Evan Longoria
(3)
Evan Longoriia
(1)
extension
(7)
fan outrage
(10)
fan rants
(2)
fanfest
(1)
FanGraphs
(3)
Farhan Zaidi
(37)
feature reliever
(1)
felony conviction
(1)
Fielding
(5)
Fielding Stats
(4)
finger injury
(3)
first post-season press conference
(3)
Francisco Peguero
(4)
Fred Lewis
(3)
Freddie Lewis
(17)
Freddie Sanchez
(4)
Freddy Sanchez
(7)
Free Agency
(8)
free agent misses
(1)
Free agent possibilities
(28)
Free agent signing
(22)
Free agent signings
(21)
front office
(3)
Gabe Kapler
(1)
Game Score
(3)
gamer-tude
(1)
Garrett Williams
(1)
Gary Brown
(26)
Geno Espinelli
(1)
George Kontos
(10)
Ghosts of Giants Drafts
(2)
Giants
(10)
Giants Announcer
(1)
Giants blogs
(3)
Giants Chat
(4)
Giants Classic Rotation
(1)
Giants Defense
(4)
Giants Draft
(15)
Giants Drafts
(9)
Giants Farm System
(34)
Giants Franchise record
(2)
Giants Future
(66)
Giants GM
(12)
Giants Greats
(3)
Giants hitting manual
(1)
Giants Leadership
(1)
Giants manager
(1)
Giants No-Hitter
(5)
Giants Offense
(34)
Giants Offseason
(24)
Giants Pitching
(10)
Giants President of Baseball Operations
(4)
Giants Strategy
(44)
GiDar
(1)
Gino Espinelli
(1)
glossary
(1)
Gold Glove Award
(1)
good players
(4)
good will
(1)
Gorkys Hernandez
(2)
Graphical Player
(1)
great players
(4)
Gregor Blanco
(18)
Gregor Moscoso
(1)
Gregory Santos
(1)
Guillermo Moscoso
(2)
Guillermo Mota
(2)
Guillermo Quiroz
(1)
Gustavo Cabrera
(4)
Hall of Fame
(10)
Hall of Shame
(4)
Hank Aaron
(5)
Happy Holidays
(2)
Hate mail
(1)
Hayden Birdsong
(2)
healthy
(1)
heart-warming
(1)
Heath Hembree
(8)
Heath Quinn
(1)
Hector Correa
(1)
Hector Sanchez
(12)
Heliot Ramos
(13)
Henry Sosa
(8)
HGH
(1)
Hidden Game
(1)
high expectations
(1)
high school focus in draft
(1)
high velocity hitters
(1)
high velocity pitchers
(1)
hiring
(2)
hiring process
(1)
Hitter's League
(1)
Hitting
(19)
Hitting Coach
(1)
hitting mechanics
(3)
hitting pitchers
(2)
hitting streak
(1)
Hitting;
(1)
Home Run Career Record
(7)
Home Run Hitting Contest
(1)
Hunter Bishop
(4)
Hunter Pence
(25)
Hunter Stickland
(1)
Hunter Strickland
(9)
Ian Gardeck
(1)
Idea
(4)
IFA
(1)
improvement
(2)
Indictment
(1)
Infield
(1)
injury
(7)
instant replay
(2)
instructor
(1)
Interesting Question
(1)
International Free Agent Pursuits
(5)
International Signings
(5)
interview
(5)
Investment
(1)
Ivan Ochoa
(2)
J.P. Martinez
(1)
J2
(1)
Jack Taschner
(4)
Jackson Williams
(3)
Jacob Dunnington
(1)
Jacob Gonzalez
(2)
Jacob Junis
(1)
Jacob McCasland
(1)
Jae-gyun Hwang
(1)
Jake Dunning
(2)
Jake Peavy
(39)
Jake Smith
(1)
Jake Wong
(1)
Jalen Miller
(1)
Jandel Gustave
(1)
Japanese Starters
(1)
Jarrett Parker
(10)
Jason Heyward
(1)
Jason Maxwell
(2)
Jason Stoffel
(1)
Javier Lopez
(5)
JC Gutierrez
(3)
JD Davis
(1)
Jean Machi
(6)
Jeff Kent
(1)
Jeff Samardzija
(28)
Jeff Suppan
(1)
Jeremy Affeldt
(12)
Jeremy Shelley
(2)
Jerome Williams
(1)
Jesse English
(2)
Jesse Foppert
(1)
Jesus Guzman
(4)
Jimmy Rollins
(1)
Joaquin Arias
(14)
Joe Panik
(18)
Joe Torre
(1)
Joey Bart
(6)
Joey Martinez
(2)
Johan Santana
(1)
John Barr
(1)
John Bowker
(22)
John Thorn
(1)
Johneshwy Fargas
(2)
Johnny Bench
(1)
Johnny Cueto
(31)
Johnny Monell
(1)
Johnny Rucker
(1)
Jonah Arenado
(1)
Jonathan Mayo
(1)
Jonathan Sanchez
(49)
Jordan Hicks
(1)
Jordan Johnson
(1)
Jorge Soler
(2)
Jose Canseco
(1)
Jose Casilla
(1)
Jose Guillen
(3)
Jose Mijares
(3)
Jose Uribe
(2)
Josh Osich
(9)
JT Snow
(1)
Juan Perez
(6)
Juan Uribe
(9)
Juggling Monkey
(1)
Julian Fernandez
(7)
Julio Urias
(1)
Jung Hoo Lee
(4)
jury
(1)
Just Say No
(1)
Keaton Winn
(1)
Kelby Tomlinson
(5)
Kendry Flores
(2)
Keury Mella
(2)
Kevin Correia
(2)
Kevin Frandsen
(22)
Kevin Gausman
(3)
Kevin Pillar
(2)
Kevin Pucetas
(10)
KNBR
(1)
Kung Fu Panda
(30)
Kyle Crick
(16)
Kyle Harrison
(7)
laid off
(1)
Landen Roupp
(1)
Larry Baer
(3)
Larry Ellison
(1)
Lead-off
(2)
leadoff
(1)
left-handed
(1)
Lew Wolff
(1)
LHP
(1)
Lineup
(17)
lineup construction
(4)
Lineup position
(1)
links
(1)
Logan Webb
(3)
Lon Simmons
(1)
long relief
(2)
Long-Term Contract
(22)
long-term planning
(3)
losing streak
(1)
Lucius Fox
(3)
luck
(2)
Luis Angel Mateo
(2)
Luis Matos
(2)
Luis Toribio
(1)
lunatic fringe
(1)
Mac Marshall
(1)
Mac Williamson
(12)
Madison Bumgarner
(185)
Mailbox
(1)
Malcolm Gladwell
(1)
management change
(3)
management issues
(5)
managerial value
(5)
Manny
(1)
Marc Kroon
(2)
Marco Luciano
(4)
Marco Scutaro
(12)
Mark DeRosa
(8)
Mark Gardner
(1)
Mark Melancon
(4)
Marlon Byrd
(1)
Martin Agosta
(7)
Marvin Miller
(1)
Masahiro Tanaka
(1)
Mason Black
(1)
Mason McVay
(1)
Matsuzaka
(1)
Matt Cain
(160)
Matt Chapman
(2)
Matt Daniels
(3)
Matt Downs
(2)
Matt Duffy
(8)
Matt Graham
(1)
Matt Holliday
(1)
Matt Krook
(2)
Matt Moore
(15)
Matt Morris
(2)
Mauricio Dubon
(2)
Mechanics
(4)
Media
(17)
Media Bias
(17)
media hypocrisy
(1)
Media Trade Idea
(3)
Medical
(1)
Mediocy
(11)
Mediots
(6)
Melk-Gone
(1)
Melky Cabrera
(14)
Melvin Adon
(1)
memories
(1)
mental
(1)
Merkin Valdez
(8)
Message in a Bottle
(1)
methodology
(2)
MI
(1)
Michael Conforto
(1)
Michael Main
(1)
Michael Reed
(1)
Michael Trout
(1)
middle infield
(2)
Miguel Cabrera
(2)
Miguel Gomez
(1)
Miguel Tejada
(5)
Mike Fontenot
(3)
Mike Ivie
(1)
Mike Kickham
(9)
Mike Leake
(11)
Mike Matheny
(1)
Mike Morse
(10)
Mike Yastrzemski
(1)
Mike Yazstremski
(2)
milestone
(1)
minor league
(1)
minor league contract
(4)
minors
(11)
mismanagement
(1)
misnomer
(1)
mistakes
(2)
MLB
(2)
MLB stupidity
(2)
MLB Success
(7)
MLB Trade Rumors
(1)
MLBAM
(1)
MLBTR
(1)
MLE
(1)
Mock Draft analysis
(8)
Modern Portfolio Theory
(1)
Modus Operandi
(2)
MPT
(1)
MVP
(2)
Natanael Javier
(1)
Nate Schierholtz
(45)
Nathanael Javier
(1)
Nationals
(1)
Naysayers
(2)
Negotiations
(1)
Neil Ramirez
(1)
NewPQS
(8)
Next Gen
(1)
Nick Hundley
(2)
Nick Noonan
(27)
Nick Pereira
(1)
Nick Vander Tuig
(2)
Nick Vincent
(1)
NL Champions
(2)
NL Playoffs
(1)
NL West
(29)
NL West Division Title
(20)
NL West Future
(1)
NLCS
(22)
NLCS MVP
(2)
NLDS
(8)
Noah Lowry
(14)
non-roster invitees
(2)
non-tenders
(3)
Nori Aoki
(4)
NPB
(1)
NRI
(1)
Oakland A's
(4)
OBP
(1)
oddities
(1)
Offense
(4)
offensive era
(1)
ogcPQS
(6)
Omar Vizquel
(3)
one-run games
(3)
Opener
(1)
openers
(1)
Opening Day
(6)
opening day pitcher
(3)
opening day roster
(11)
Optimism
(1)
Osiris Matos
(2)
Outfield
(3)
outfielder curse
(1)
overturned
(1)
Ownership
(7)
Pablo Sandoval
(97)
Padres
(1)
Panda
(6)
Pandoval
(1)
passing
(1)
Pat Burrell
(15)
Pat Misch
(5)
Patrick Bailey
(2)
Payroll
(11)
PECOTA
(1)
Pedro Feliz
(12)
PEDS
(10)
Perfect Game
(2)
perjury trial
(1)
personal
(2)
Personal Reminiscence
(2)
Pessimism
(1)
Pete Palmer
(1)
Pete Putila
(1)
Pete Rose
(3)
Peter Magowan
(2)
Phil Bickford
(3)
Phillies
(7)
philosophy
(1)
Phoenix Theory of Rebuilding
(1)
Pierce Johnson
(2)
Pitch Count
(3)
pitch framing
(1)
pitch value
(1)
Pitcher hitting 8th
(1)
pitcher’s health
(1)
Pitchers League
(1)
Pitching
(27)
pitching analysis
(4)
pitching department
(1)
pitching development
(4)
Pitching Rotation
(90)
pitching staff
(6)
pitching strategy
(2)
plate discipline
(1)
platoon players
(2)
Play Ball
(1)
player acquisition
(1)
player budget
(2)
player development
(8)
playoff
(2)
playoff analysis
(6)
playoff hopes
(39)
playoff roster
(2)
playoff rotation
(6)
Playoff Success
(29)
Playoff Win Effective
(3)
Playoff Win Efficient
(2)
Playoffs
(44)
postmortem
(2)
PQS
(109)
press conference
(2)
pressure
(2)
priorities
(1)
Projected Record
(6)
projection
(2)
projections
(2)
promotion
(2)
prospect
(4)
prospect analysis
(7)
prospect future
(2)
prospect handling
(1)
Prospect of Note
(3)
prospect promotion
(1)
prospect study
(3)
Prospects
(46)
quality starts
(1)
questions
(1)
radio great
(1)
Rafael Rodriquez
(8)
Rajai Davis
(2)
Ralph Barbieri
(1)
Ramon Ramirez
(3)
Randy Johnson
(10)
Randy Messenger
(2)
Randy Winn
(14)
Rangers
(5)
Ranking
(4)
rant
(1)
raspberry
(1)
rationalization
(1)
Ray Durham
(5)
Rayner Arias
(1)
re-sign
(2)
realist
(1)
Rebuilding
(5)
Rebuilding Myths series
(1)
rebuttal
(1)
Red Sox
(1)
Reds
(5)
Reggie Crawford
(1)
rehab
(1)
reliever
(3)
relievers
(1)
Relocation Concession
(2)
Research
(2)
resource scarcity
(1)
rest for starters
(1)
Retired
(3)
Retirement
(3)
return
(1)
Reyes Moronta
(3)
RHP
(1)
Ricardo Genoves
(1)
Rich Aurilia
(7)
Rick Peterson
(1)
Rickie Weeks
(1)
Ricky Oropesa
(3)
right-handed
(1)
risk mitigation
(2)
risk profile
(1)
Roberto Gomez
(1)
Rockies
(2)
Rod Beck
(1)
Roger Kieschnick
(13)
Roger Metzger
(1)
Ron Shandler
(2)
Ron Wotus
(1)
Ronnie Jebavy
(1)
Ronnie Ray
(1)
rookie debut
(1)
Rookie of the Year
(1)
Roster
(4)
rosterbation
(2)
Rotation by Committee
(1)
Rotation Chaos
(1)
ROY
(2)
Royals
(3)
Rule 5
(2)
Rule 5 Draft Pick
(5)
rumors
(9)
run differential
(1)
run prevention
(1)
run production
(1)
runs support
(1)
Russ Ortiz
(11)
Russell Carleton
(1)
Ryan Garko
(2)
Ryan Klesko
(4)
Ryan Rohlinger
(2)
Ryan Theriot
(3)
Ryan Vogelsong
(93)
Ryder Jones
(2)
Sabean Naysayers
(7)
Sabermetric Thoughts
(6)
sabermetrics
(5)
SABR
(1)
Salary speculation
(3)
SALLY
(1)
Sam Dyson
(7)
Sam Long
(1)
Sam Selman
(1)
Sam Wolff
(1)
San Jose Giants
(1)
San Jose Relocation
(3)
Sandro Fabian
(2)
Sandy Rosario
(1)
Santiago Casilla
(9)
scenarios
(1)
Scott Boras
(1)
Scott Harris
(2)
Scott McClain
(2)
Scott Shuman
(1)
Scouting
(2)
Sean Hjelle
(5)
season review
(1)
secret sauce
(2)
Sergio Romo
(17)
Seth Corry
(6)
SF Giants
(2)
Shilo McCall
(1)
Shohei Ohtani
(3)
Shohei Otani
(2)
Shooter
(1)
shutouts
(1)
Signature Song
(1)
signing
(13)
Silly-Ball
(3)
South Atlantic League
(1)
South Bay Rights
(1)
SP usage
(1)
spin rate
(1)
splits
(2)
Sports Illustrated
(1)
Spring Training
(16)
stabilized stats
(1)
standings
(1)
starting CF
(1)
starting lineup
(19)
starting pitching
(96)
starting rotation
(5)
StatCast
(2)
Statcorner
(1)
State of the Giants
(1)
statistics
(2)
STATS
(1)
Steamer
(1)
Stephen Vogt
(1)
Steroids
(7)
Steve Edlefsen
(4)
Steve Johnson
(3)
Steve Okert
(8)
Steven Duggar
(7)
strikeout rate
(2)
Sue Burns
(1)
sunk costs
(1)
superstition
(1)
tactics
(1)
talent evaluation
(4)
Tax
(1)
team culture
(1)
Team of the 2010's
(2)
Team of the 2020's
(1)
Team of the Decade
(4)
Team Speed
(1)
Team Support
(1)
Thank You
(2)
The Evil Ones (tm)
(1)
The Giants Way
(2)
The Hardball Times
(1)
The Hey Series
(19)
The Hey Zaidi Series
(4)
Thomas Joseph
(3)
Thomas Neal
(9)
Tigers
(4)
Tim Alderson
(17)
Tim Hudson
(39)
Tim Lincecum
(195)
TINSTAAPP
(1)
Todd Linden
(3)
Todd Wellemeyer
(6)
Tommy Joseph
(3)
Tony Watson
(4)
Top 100 Prospects
(1)
Top 14 Roster
(1)
Top Draft Position
(4)
top Giants prospects
(6)
top player list
(1)
top prospect list
(6)
Trade
(12)
Trade Analysis
(22)
Trade Idea
(9)
Trade PTBNL
(2)
Trade Rumors
(30)
trading
(1)
training staff
(2)
Training Tool
(1)
transitional season
(1)
Travis Blackley
(1)
Travis Ishikawa
(47)
Trevor Brown
(5)
Trevor Gott
(1)
tribute
(1)
Tristan Beck
(2)
turning point
(1)
Ty Blach
(23)
Tyler Austin
(1)
Tyler Beede
(10)
Tyler Cyr
(1)
Tyler Horan
(1)
Tyler McDonald
(1)
Tyler Rogers
(2)
Tyler Walker
(2)
umpire mistake
(3)
Umpires
(3)
USA Today
(1)
utility
(1)
Voros McCracken
(1)
Waiver Roulette
(1)
Waldis Joaquin
(5)
walks
(1)
Wall of Fame
(1)
WAR
(4)
Warrior Spirit
(1)
Wendell Fairley
(10)
What-If Scenario
(3)
wild card
(1)
wild card race
(1)
Will Bednar
(1)
Will Clark
(1)
Will Smith
(7)
Will Wilson
(3)
Williams Jerez
(1)
Willie Mac Award
(1)
Willie Mays
(1)
winning on the road
(1)
Winter League
(1)
winter meetings
(3)
World Series
(28)
World Series Champions
(13)
WS Ring Bling
(1)
xBABIP
(1)
xwOBA
(1)
Yankees
(1)
Yusmeiro Petit
(40)
Zack Cozart
(2)
Zack Minasian
(1)
Zack Wheeler
(9)
Zaidi Haters
(1)
Zaidi MO
(2)
Zaidi Rotation
(3)
ZiPS
(1)
Zito Role
(2)
Of Sanchez v. Zito, you make many good points about sequencing. But the one about how Sanchez is the "5th Starter?" Not as good. Saying it was because Sanchez's favorite color is purple would make as much sense. The label of "5th starter" has no meaning. The label of "Worst Starter" would have plenty of meaning. But I don't think anyone would say Sanchez is definitively that.
ReplyDeleteAll that said, Zito had an interesting outing today. Hope it's a sign of things to come.
The Giants have virtually no input into the schedule, they just have to deal with it. Clearly, you do not want schedule anomalies to impact your 1,2,3 starters. So 4 or 5 get screwed with. I think the giants got this one right, keeping iron man, never miss a start Zito in the rotation and easing up on the guy who barely got thru last year, who really faded in the second half and, finally, had to be shut down. Clearly, there is some question that Sanchez can get thru a 162 game schedule. Since the choice is forced on the team, I say, yes, sit the guy who, in the long run, can probably use the rest.
ReplyDeleteJohn, I think we all know who is the better pitcher, I was only talking about Sanchez being the 5th starter in the starting rotation, and how MLB teams regularly skip the 5th starter's spot in the rotation when necessary.
ReplyDeleteAnd per allfrank's excellent point, Sanchez has been innings challenged in that he faded greatly once he hit the roughly 100 IP barrier last year, and pretty much lost it all after the 115 IP level, so I doubt he could have increased his endurance by over 50% in order to last through a regular 180-200 IP season as a starter. Thus, skipping his spot in the rotation occasionally would allow him to pitch deeper and more effectively into the season, and have less bad starts overall.
In addition, he has more experience doing starting and relieving during a season than Zito has.
Saying that there are fears about him hitting 180 innings is fine. (Although if we don't have faith in this by now, I'm sort of wondering why people feel so confident about SF's staff.) My point above was that if I want to hear Bochy-isms which are sanitized for public consumption and not rocking the boat, I can listen to everyone on KNBR apart from the late night guy. I come here and other sites because I expect people to be, forgive the expression, keeping it real.
ReplyDeleteSo, saying clubs regularly skip their 5th starter because they're the 5th starter, don't you get that doesn't convince me that it's the right thing to do. It's a meaningless label and I'd love to root for a club which makes decisions like this based upon considerations other than "he's our 5th starter."
Or, put another way, Zito was SF's "#1 starter" for 2008.
Sorry to disappoint you, John, but I thought I was keeping it real.
ReplyDeleteWe are dealing with human beings here, not chess pieces. It's easy to say "skip Zito, he's the low man on the talent totem pole". People's confidence and belief in their manager's leadership and support of them can hinge on things like this.
Skip Zito, and you might flush down $100M for the next 5 seasons for us, as he would both think that Bochy and Giants management has no confidence in him. Is that real enough?
We have to give him the benefit of the doubt right now: we have no choice. That's what I've been writing about since last season, if you are a true Giants fan, you have to try to stay positive and encouraging with Zito because you have no choice, else you are dealing with a nuclear winter on our budget for the next 5 seasons with nothing to show for it.
And being supportive doesn't mean giving him the #1 label, it has to do with saying he's terrible, throw him aside, ignore his feelings, he has no right because he's paid so much, those are not supportive.
He's the elephant in the room (pun unintended, then intended :^) and we have to deal with him. Luckily, it could be easily justified to push him to #4 this season, but last season you had to give him his due and make him #1 even though none of us thought he was. I think that's being very real.
Thinking you can skip Zito and not have any fallout from that is what I would call not being real.
RE: Velez and Torres
ReplyDeleteOf the two, Torres is definitely the better player. He has good defense and makes decent contact, which are the missing components in Velez's game. Torres is also fast, negating Velez's only asset.
Ergo: Send Velez down. Frandsen is a better utility player in case we need another position player.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDon't want to turn this into a talking past you event. I think the "might flush 100M" line is overkill. Zito was skipped last season and the world did not end. It would only become a thing if Bochy made it a thing. The investment is a sunk cost and if skipping one start endangers it, we all should get comfortable with the flushing noise.
ReplyDeleteMore broadly, I was only trying to call out the "Sanchez is the 5th starter" label. It's meaningless, I think we agree it's meaningless if everyone is wink-wink/nudge-nudge, this is only to protect Zito's ego.
Some might call this a high-class problem, but before yesterday's start, it was not not hard to envision a point a month or two from now when Zito is, unambiguously, the worst starter on the staff. I'm really hoping Zito prevents that from happening, but it's certainly possible. When that happens, decisions may need to be made to reflect that.
To put that into even greater relief, let's assume Zito has a 2009 which looks like 2008 but that Sanchez shows durability and consistency throughout the season. And somehow, miracle-of-miracles, the Giants win the West. (An even higher class problem I'll admit.) If you had to decide who to put into a long relief role, would you take Zito's contract then? Different problem, sure. But, at bottom, if a guy can't accept getting benched for performance reasons, he's no good to the club, no matter how much you've spent on him.
This is exactly the kind of situation Zito can be reasonably expected to return any value on contract – As an innings sponge. It is not like the Giants are setting up a play off rotation here; it is mid April and it is all about pacing things.
ReplyDeleteIf Sanchez had thrown 150-160 innings last season but the last 50 IP are much more like first 100 IP of ’08 then we get excited about this stuff tell can turn in 150P season with out a huge drop off he is learning and Big Head should doing what he can to lessen the chances Sanchez blows his arm out by September.
I don't think it's overkill, but as always, just my opinion. You see a similar situation, I see a world of difference.
ReplyDeleteWhen Zito was skipped last time, he had been scuffling for about half the season at that point, and just not figuring things out. By that point, it was not a matter of managerial confidence in him, it was about him abysmally failing.
If you skip him now, after two lousy starts, so early in the season, it becomes an issue for Zito of "Does Bochy and Sabean have so little confidence in me that they skip over me for the #5 starter?"
So yeah, I think that is a real consequence of skipping him now. And particularly bad time too, he's been showing greater velocity, he's been showing greater stuff, why skip his turn when he is showing that he's pitching OK but just not getting results?
The only reason I called Sanchez the #5 starter is because he's the 5th starter for the season. Anybody who has been reading my blog for any length of time should know that I think the world of him, and I think he can be as good as Cain (and perhaps Lincecum) with time and experience. That's why, as I wrote about last year, I was relieved when I was in a keeper league and another Giants fan grabbed Brian Wilson and "neenered" me, I grabbed Sanchez and had a sigh of relief.
I thought that Zito has the least talent on the staff pre-season, we don't need to get too deep into the season to say that. Lincecum and Sanchez can totally dominate the other team and rack up the strikeouts. Cain is efficiently professional in putting down the other side. And Johnson has been doing it for years. Zito is not a staff ace, he's only paid like one.
However, he's a vet who can eat up a lot of innings, which still has a lot of value, and with his velocity up, he could be a pretty decent starter too, I mean, if he can just do what he did for the A's his last two seasons, with a high 3 ERA, for the rest of the contract, that would be worth the money we are paying him and more. Particularly since he'll be doing it from the back of the rotation, facing lesser pitchers, and as a result, winning a lot of games.
He ate humble pie when the Giants skipped his spot in the rotation and he was a professional about that, and used that as motivation to do better, which he then did. Again, whole world difference between struggling for half a season and getting nowhere and basically the start of the season, only two bad starts with signs of hope, when we don't know which Zito we got.
But yeah, if he is struggling like he has the past two years for an extended period, I would expect him to suck it up and take the benching. This was not the time to be benching him, there is nothing to be gained, a lot to be lost.
But that's a good question regarding the playoffs, who would we bench? I think whoever is doing worst at the end would have to bite the bullet. And Zito has always been a second half guy, and he can dominate when he is going good, whereas Sanchez wore out last season at 100 IP. If I were a prudent manager, unless Sanchez was shutting out teams left and right at the end, I go with Zito in 2009 because you don't know when Sanchez will hit the wall, but by 2010, I would probably go with Sanchez because he should have the stamina by then. Zito should understand that performance is what gets rewarded in the playoffs.
But fans need to remember that stamina is a key component of performance in baseball, it is because we play 162 games, and you can't just go by how well a guy is pitching, it is a combination of his pitching and his stamina. And Zito had that in spades, and if he returns to his high 3's ERA standard, that is still a very good pitcher.
So I see your points, and basically agree with them, but I think you are jumping the gun here, they are not similar situations.
Just read daveinexile: what he said. :^)
ReplyDelete