The great Andy Baggarly posted his transcript for the 2009 Giants Post-Season Press Conference at his blog recently. Chris Haft just posted his transcripts, but with the actual questions asked, at his blog, but it is unclear whether he provided the whole Q&A session or just select questions, as I haven't compared his with Baggarly's yet.
I normally go through the transcripts and give my thoughts and opinions on each answer, but just too busy with work right now. But I wanted to link to both transcripts, just in case someone hasn't seen either yet.
I will try to write my usual stuff on this over the weekend, and otherwise will be quiet unless some big Giants news come out.
But here are some initial thoughts.
Typical Brian Sabean press conference: nothing really newsworthy, no blockbuster as usual, but some good hints as to 2010, like Freddy Sanchez most probably coming back, and the budget being about the same, and, of course, some defensive posturing, this time regarding Edgar Renteria.
Free Agency Pursuits
The more I think about it, the more I'm convinced that the Giants will get someone to make a statement for next season. Sabean intimated that something has to be done, and free agency is the easiest route.
As I noted before Holliday is out of reach, and I've reached the point where I think Bay is out too. The more I look at Ankiel, the more I don't think we are going after him, particularly since Boras is his agent, I believe. But those are the only OF that makes any sense, powerwise and age-wise, though Gary Sheffield is available, but hasn't played a full season for years now.
An interesting option, however, is Mike Cameron, who is great defensively in the OF and has good pop in his bat, he hit 24 HR last season. The only issue is that he's 37 next season. Maybe Rowand would be willing to move to RF and let Cameron take CF, then Cameron could bat 3rd, making it Velez/Torres LF, Franchez 2B, Cameron CF, Pandoval 3B, Renteria SS, IshiGarko 1B, Rowand RF, FA C (or maybe Posey, in which case, he hits 6th and push down).
That brings us to 3B. Adrian Beltre could be one target, he's great defensively at 3B and has some pop in his bat, though not what we are looking for. Joe Crede is another one, though Boras is his agent too (Hmmm, Beltre too, now that I think of it). Chone Figgins can play 3B and the OF, so he could be an option: he could leadoff, since he has a lot of speed, plus play at a number of positions, 2B, 3B, LF, CF, allowing flexibility in where they play him while playing him full-time. There is also Miquel Tejada, he's been an RBI producer, but he hit pretty bad outside of Houston so I hope the Giants don't pursue him.
At 1B, the choice many would suggest is Hank Blalock. Just say NO! He is horrible outside of Texas. He can credit his ballpark for him making it to free agency, otherwise, he would have been sent down long ago. Nick Johnson and Adam LaRoche are nice options, but Johnson is very injury prone while LaRoche has benefited from good home parks, hitting less than 800 OPS on the road, which is OK if he was good defensively, but he isn't. Russell Branyan is an interesting choice, given his nice 2008, but he'll be 34 and I'll bet his defense isn't any good on the corners either. Carlos Delgado would fill the need but at 38, could have had his last good season already, plus was injured in 2009.
Actually, there are two other options in the OF: Bobby Abreu and Brian Giles. Sabean mentioned during the session that the Giants might have to go in another direction because there is not a lot of power options out there, meaning OBP. These are two very high OBP guys, and have enough power to bat 3rd in the lineup. Both are pretty old, though, and could decline in 2010, just like Cameron might.
Other options include DHers and former OFs, Vlad Guerrerro and Hideki Matsui. Both are old and declining, and probably not that good in the OF anymore. But both have been middle of the lineup hitters before, so they are also possibilities in the OF, just not likely. There are also Aubrey Huff and Jim Thome, but age and decline dooms Thome, and Huff isn't any good defensively, if I remember right.
So, really, there are no clearly good options in free agency for the Giants situation.
That means that Sabean might be forced to trade for someone, which at best means whoever he can get for Jonathan Sanchez, because I don't think Cain is going anywhere. Power hitters who are free agents after next season might be appealing: Garrett Atkins, Carl Crawford (assuming his option picked up this off-season), Derrek Lee, Carlos Pena, Ty Wigginton, Scott Rolen.
The latter two might be obtainable without giving up much, as both have big negatives, Wigginton plays poor defense and Rolen is injury prone. Lee might be easy because of age and they have some good prospects coming up on the corners (Fox and Vitters), so they might be happy to dump his salary and go younger and cheaper. I don't think Crawford is going anywhere with Ricciardo fired, they are probably not doing anything until a new GM comes in. Atkins has already been pushed aside by Ian Stewart, and Helton is still at 1B, but they probably would not want to deal him to another NL West team, particularly the one they will most probably be competing against in 2010.
Pena is a possibility, as we could give them Garko and a lot of other prospects, if they want to save some money (but have not heard that money is a problem, yet). I also heard that they are tired of BJ Upton's act, but would a Sanchez be enough to land him? Probably not, given that Sanchez is arbitration eligible.
All in all, nothing really obvious among the free agents, either signing or trading for. Sabean will have a tough job to make a truly positive change to the offense without giving up a lot.
These are just my opinions. I cannot promise that I will be perfect, but I can promise that I will seek to understand and illuminate whatever moves that the Giants make (my obsession and compulsion). I will share my love of baseball and my passion for the Giants. And I will try to teach, best that I can. Often, I tackle the prevailing mood among Giants fans and see if that is a correct stance, good or bad.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
1984 Draft
(1)
2007 Draft
(15)
2007 Giants
(52)
2008 Draft
(22)
2008 Giants
(53)
2008 season
(6)
2009 Draft
(18)
2009 Giants
(87)
2009 season
(24)
2010 Decade
(12)
2010 Draft
(11)
2010 Giants
(137)
2010 NL ROY award
(1)
2010 season
(19)
2010's
(3)
2011 Draft
(9)
2011 Giants
(84)
2011 season
(8)
2012 Draft
(11)
2012 Giants
(93)
2012 season
(11)
2013 Draft
(3)
2013 Giants
(39)
2013 season
(5)
2014
(1)
2014 draft
(5)
2014 Giants
(79)
2014 season
(16)
2015 Draft
(4)
2015 Giants
(50)
2015 season
(10)
2016 Draft
(1)
2016 Giants
(45)
2016 season
(6)
2017 Draft
(3)
2017 Giants
(27)
2018 Draft
(8)
2018 Giants
(50)
2018 Season
(8)
2019 Draft
(1)
2019 Giants
(27)
2019 season
(2)
2020 Decade
(1)
2020 Giants
(9)
20201 Draft
(1)
2021 Giants
(3)
2022 Giants
(2)
2023 Giants
(14)
2023 season
(1)
2024 Giants
(18)
2025 Giants
(2)
25 man roster
(11)
25th man fallacy
(1)
26 man roster
(1)
3B
(1)
40 Man Roster
(11)
49ers
(1)
5-day rotation
(1)
51/49 decisions
(1)
6-man rotation
(5)
89 Quake
(1)
89 World Series
(1)
A-Ball
(1)
A-Gon
(1)
A-Rod
(3)
A's
(6)
AA-Ball
(1)
Aaron Rowand
(25)
Abiatal Avelino
(1)
accomplishments
(1)
ace pitcher
(2)
ace starter
(4)
Adalberto Mejia
(6)
Adam Duvall
(5)
AFL
(4)
aggression
(1)
AL Playoffs
(1)
Albert Suarez
(5)
Alen Hanson
(3)
Alex Cobb
(1)
Alex Dickerson
(2)
Alex Hinshaw
(3)
Alex Pavlovic
(1)
Alexander Canario
(2)
All-Star Game
(1)
almost perfect game
(1)
Alonzo Powell
(1)
Amphetamine
(3)
analysis
(24)
Andre Torres
(14)
Andres Torres
(2)
Andrew Baiiley
(1)
Andrew Bailey
(1)
Andrew McCutchen
(2)
Andrew Suarez
(5)
Andrew Susac
(11)
Andy Baggerly
(2)
Andy Sisco
(1)
Andy Suarez
(9)
Angel Joseph
(1)
Angel Pagan
(17)
Angel Villalona
(30)
Anniversary
(1)
appendicitis
(1)
Aramis Garcia
(2)
Arbitration
(19)
Armando Benitez
(5)
Armando Gallaraga
(1)
art of failure
(1)
Asia-Pacific signing
(1)
assessment
(1)
Astros
(3)
At the Rate They Are Going
(1)
ATT Park
(1)
Aubrey Huff
(20)
Austin Jackson
(2)
Austin Slater
(5)
Award
(4)
BABIP
(3)
Bam Bam Meulens
(1)
Barry Bonds
(30)
Barry Zito
(77)
baseball
(1)
Baseball America
(3)
Baseball Prospectus
(6)
Baseball Prospectus Bias Against Giants
(4)
baseball strategy
(9)
Baseball Study
(18)
baserunning
(2)
batting peripherals
(1)
batting stance analysis
(1)
batting title champion
(1)
Beat LA
(9)
bench players
(4)
Bengie Molina
(14)
Benjamin Snyder
(1)
Bert Blyleven
(1)
best manager
(2)
best practices
(2)
Beyond the Box Score
(1)
Bias Against Giants
(1)
Big 6
(9)
Big Picture
(3)
Bill Hall
(1)
Bill James
(1)
Bill James Handbook
(2)
Bill Mueller
(1)
Bill Neukom
(21)
Billy Beane
(3)
biography
(1)
Blake Riverra
(1)
Blake Snell
(1)
blog news
(3)
Blog Philosophy
(3)
Bob Howry
(2)
Bob Mariano
(1)
Bobby Evans
(4)
Boston Red Sox
(1)
Brad Hennessey
(5)
Brad Penny
(2)
Brandon Bednar
(1)
Brandon Belt
(50)
Brandon Crawford
(25)
Brandon Hicks
(1)
Braves
(5)
breakout
(2)
Brett Bochy
(4)
Brett Pill
(9)
Brewers
(1)
Brian Anderson
(1)
Brian Bannister
(3)
Brian Bocock
(2)
Brian Cooper
(1)
Brian Horwitz
(3)
Brian Ragira
(2)
Brian Sabean
(50)
Brian Wilson
(14)
Bridegrooms
(6)
Bruce Bochy
(36)
Bryce Eldridge
(2)
Bucky Showalter
(1)
bulllpen
(8)
Bullpen
(33)
Business Plan
(24)
Buster Posey
(105)
Byran Reynolds
(2)
Byung-Hyun Kim
(1)
Cained
(4)
call-ups
(3)
Candlestick Park
(1)
Cards
(13)
Career Prospects
(4)
Carl Hubbell
(1)
Carlos Beltran
(4)
Carlos Gomez
(1)
Carney Lansford
(2)
Carson Whisenhunt
(2)
Carter Jurica
(1)
Casey Kelly
(1)
Casey McGeHee
(3)
catcher injury
(5)
catching
(3)
CBT penalty
(1)
CC Sabathia
(1)
censorship
(2)
CEO
(2)
Chad Gaudin
(5)
Charles Culberson
(5)
Charlie Culberson
(3)
Chase Johnson
(3)
cheating
(1)
Chillax
(1)
Chris Brown
(1)
Chris Gloor
(1)
Chris Heston
(19)
Chris Lincecum
(1)
Chris Marrero
(1)
Chris O'Leary
(1)
Chris Ray
(4)
Chris Shaw
(4)
Chris Stewart
(4)
Chris Stratton
(30)
Chris Strattton
(1)
Christian Arroyo
(7)
Christmas
(1)
Christopher Dominguez
(4)
Christy Mathewson
(1)
Chuckie Jones
(2)
Clay Hensley
(3)
Clayton Blackburn
(10)
Clayton Tanner
(3)
Closer
(9)
closer by committee
(3)
Coaches
(4)
coaching changes
(1)
Cody Hall
(2)
Cody Ross
(8)
Col
(1)
Comeback Award
(1)
Commissioner
(1)
comparison
(3)
competitive advantage
(1)
Competitive Balance Tax
(2)
Competitive Cycles
(2)
competitiveness
(2)
Conner Menez
(1)
Connor Joe
(3)
Connor Nurse
(1)
Conor Gillaspie
(25)
contender
(1)
contract extension
(3)
contract negotiations
(2)
contract signing
(7)
Coordinator
(1)
core competency
(1)
Core Rotation
(1)
Cory Gearrin
(5)
Cory Guerrin
(1)
Cory Hart
(1)
Craig Whitaker
(2)
Cubs
(1)
Curt Young
(1)
cuts
(1)
Cy Young Award
(5)
cyber-relief
(1)
D-backs
(16)
D-gers
(36)
D-Rocks
(3)
D-Rox
(17)
D.J. Snelten
(3)
Dallas McPherson
(1)
Dan Ortmeier
(11)
Dan Otero
(2)
Dan Runzler
(6)
Dan Slania
(3)
Dan Uggla
(1)
Daniel Carbonell
(1)
Daniel Slania
(2)
Dany Jimenez
(1)
Darren Ford
(1)
Dave Righetti
(1)
Dave Roberts
(11)
David Aardsma
(1)
David Bell
(1)
David Huff
(2)
David Loewenstein
(1)
Decade of the Giants
(12)
decline
(1)
Defense
(11)
Deferred Money
(1)
deleted comment
(1)
Denard Span
(3)
depth
(1)
Dereck Rodriquez
(7)
Derek Holland
(18)
Derek Law
(11)
Detroit Tigers
(1)
DFA
(3)
DH
(2)
Dick Tidrow
(2)
dictionary
(1)
direction
(1)
Dirty
(1)
DL
(3)
dodgers
(15)
Donald Snelten
(1)
Donovan Solano
(1)
Draft
(11)
Draft Analysis
(28)
Draft Bonus
(7)
draft list
(3)
draft philosophy
(2)
draft signing
(3)
Draft Strategy
(12)
Draft Study
(9)
Draft Success
(4)
drafting
(5)
Dres
(16)
Drew Pomeranz
(1)
DRS
(1)
Dynasty
(3)
Earl Weaver
(1)
Edgar Renteria
(13)
Eduardo Nunez
(4)
Edwin Escobar
(5)
Ehire Adrianza
(26)
Eli Whiteside
(4)
Elimination game
(1)
EME
(2)
Emmanuel Burriss
(18)
end of an era
(1)
epic season
(6)
era
(1)
Eric Byrnes
(1)
Eric Surkamp
(6)
Erik Cordier
(1)
Eugenio Velez
(12)
evaluation
(3)
Evan Longoria
(3)
Evan Longoriia
(1)
extension
(7)
fan outrage
(10)
fan rants
(2)
fanfest
(1)
FanGraphs
(3)
Farhan Zaidi
(37)
feature reliever
(1)
felony conviction
(1)
Fielding
(5)
Fielding Stats
(4)
finger injury
(3)
first post-season press conference
(3)
Francisco Peguero
(4)
Fred Lewis
(3)
Freddie Lewis
(17)
Freddie Sanchez
(4)
Freddy Sanchez
(7)
Free Agency
(8)
free agent misses
(1)
Free agent possibilities
(28)
Free agent signing
(22)
Free agent signings
(21)
front office
(3)
Gabe Kapler
(1)
Game Score
(3)
gamer-tude
(1)
Garrett Williams
(1)
Gary Brown
(26)
Geno Espinelli
(1)
George Kontos
(10)
Ghosts of Giants Drafts
(2)
Giants
(10)
Giants Announcer
(1)
Giants blogs
(3)
Giants Chat
(4)
Giants Classic Rotation
(1)
Giants Defense
(4)
Giants Draft
(15)
Giants Drafts
(9)
Giants Farm System
(34)
Giants Franchise record
(2)
Giants Future
(66)
Giants GM
(13)
Giants Greats
(3)
Giants hitting manual
(1)
Giants Leadership
(1)
Giants manager
(1)
Giants No-Hitter
(5)
Giants Offense
(34)
Giants Offseason
(24)
Giants Pitching
(10)
Giants President of Baseball Operations
(5)
Giants Strategy
(45)
GiDar
(1)
Gino Espinelli
(1)
glossary
(1)
Gold Glove Award
(1)
good players
(4)
good will
(1)
Gorkys Hernandez
(2)
Graphical Player
(1)
great players
(4)
Gregor Blanco
(18)
Gregor Moscoso
(1)
Gregory Santos
(1)
Guillermo Moscoso
(2)
Guillermo Mota
(2)
Guillermo Quiroz
(1)
Gustavo Cabrera
(4)
Hall of Fame
(10)
Hall of Shame
(4)
Hank Aaron
(5)
Happy Holidays
(2)
Hate mail
(1)
Hayden Birdsong
(2)
healthy
(1)
heart-warming
(1)
Heath Hembree
(8)
Heath Quinn
(1)
Hector Correa
(1)
Hector Sanchez
(12)
Heliot Ramos
(13)
Henry Sosa
(8)
HGH
(1)
Hidden Game
(1)
high expectations
(1)
high school focus in draft
(1)
high velocity hitters
(1)
high velocity pitchers
(1)
hiring
(2)
hiring process
(1)
Hitter's League
(1)
Hitting
(19)
Hitting Coach
(1)
hitting mechanics
(3)
hitting pitchers
(2)
hitting streak
(1)
Hitting;
(1)
Home Run Career Record
(7)
Home Run Hitting Contest
(1)
Hunter Bishop
(4)
Hunter Pence
(25)
Hunter Stickland
(1)
Hunter Strickland
(9)
Ian Gardeck
(1)
Idea
(4)
IFA
(1)
improvement
(2)
Indictment
(1)
Infield
(1)
injury
(7)
instant replay
(2)
instructor
(1)
Interesting Question
(1)
International Free Agent Pursuits
(5)
International Signings
(5)
interview
(5)
Investment
(1)
Ivan Ochoa
(2)
J.P. Martinez
(1)
J2
(1)
Jack Taschner
(4)
Jackson Williams
(3)
Jacob Dunnington
(1)
Jacob Gonzalez
(2)
Jacob Junis
(1)
Jacob McCasland
(1)
Jae-gyun Hwang
(1)
Jake Dunning
(2)
Jake Peavy
(39)
Jake Smith
(1)
Jake Wong
(1)
Jalen Miller
(1)
Jandel Gustave
(1)
Japanese Starters
(1)
Jarrett Parker
(10)
Jason Heyward
(1)
Jason Maxwell
(2)
Jason Stoffel
(1)
Javier Lopez
(5)
JC Gutierrez
(3)
JD Davis
(1)
Jean Machi
(6)
Jeff Kent
(1)
Jeff Samardzija
(28)
Jeff Suppan
(1)
Jeremy Affeldt
(12)
Jeremy Shelley
(2)
Jerome Williams
(1)
Jesse English
(2)
Jesse Foppert
(1)
Jesus Guzman
(4)
Jimmy Rollins
(1)
Joaquin Arias
(14)
Joe Panik
(18)
Joe Torre
(1)
Joey Bart
(6)
Joey Martinez
(2)
Johan Santana
(1)
John Barr
(1)
John Bowker
(22)
John Thorn
(1)
Johneshwy Fargas
(2)
Johnny Bench
(1)
Johnny Cueto
(31)
Johnny Monell
(1)
Johnny Rucker
(1)
Jonah Arenado
(1)
Jonathan Mayo
(1)
Jonathan Sanchez
(49)
Jordan Hicks
(1)
Jordan Johnson
(1)
Jorge Soler
(2)
Jose Canseco
(1)
Jose Casilla
(1)
Jose Guillen
(3)
Jose Mijares
(3)
Jose Uribe
(2)
Josh Osich
(9)
JT Snow
(1)
Juan Perez
(6)
Juan Uribe
(9)
Juggling Monkey
(1)
Julian Fernandez
(7)
Julio Urias
(1)
Jung Hoo Lee
(4)
jury
(1)
Just Say No
(1)
Keaton Winn
(1)
Kelby Tomlinson
(5)
Kendry Flores
(2)
Keury Mella
(2)
Kevin Correia
(2)
Kevin Frandsen
(22)
Kevin Gausman
(3)
Kevin Pillar
(2)
Kevin Pucetas
(10)
KNBR
(1)
Kung Fu Panda
(30)
Kyle Crick
(16)
Kyle Harrison
(7)
laid off
(1)
Landen Roupp
(1)
Larry Baer
(3)
Larry Ellison
(1)
Lead-off
(2)
leadoff
(1)
left-handed
(1)
Lew Wolff
(1)
LHP
(1)
Lineup
(17)
lineup construction
(4)
Lineup position
(1)
links
(1)
Logan Webb
(3)
Lon Simmons
(1)
long relief
(2)
Long-Term Contract
(22)
long-term planning
(3)
losing streak
(1)
Lucius Fox
(3)
luck
(2)
Luis Angel Mateo
(2)
Luis Matos
(2)
Luis Toribio
(1)
lunatic fringe
(1)
Mac Marshall
(1)
Mac Williamson
(12)
Madison Bumgarner
(185)
Mailbox
(1)
Malcolm Gladwell
(1)
management change
(3)
management issues
(5)
managerial value
(5)
Manny
(1)
Marc Kroon
(2)
Marco Luciano
(4)
Marco Scutaro
(12)
Mark DeRosa
(8)
Mark Gardner
(1)
Mark Melancon
(4)
Marlon Byrd
(1)
Martin Agosta
(7)
Marvin Miller
(1)
Masahiro Tanaka
(1)
Mason Black
(1)
Mason McVay
(1)
Matsuzaka
(1)
Matt Cain
(160)
Matt Chapman
(2)
Matt Daniels
(3)
Matt Downs
(2)
Matt Duffy
(8)
Matt Graham
(1)
Matt Holliday
(1)
Matt Krook
(2)
Matt Moore
(15)
Matt Morris
(2)
Mauricio Dubon
(2)
Mechanics
(4)
Media
(17)
Media Bias
(17)
media hypocrisy
(1)
Media Trade Idea
(3)
Medical
(1)
Mediocy
(11)
Mediots
(6)
Melk-Gone
(1)
Melky Cabrera
(14)
Melvin Adon
(1)
memories
(1)
mental
(1)
Merkin Valdez
(8)
Message in a Bottle
(1)
methodology
(2)
MI
(1)
Michael Conforto
(1)
Michael Main
(1)
Michael Reed
(1)
Michael Trout
(1)
middle infield
(2)
Miguel Cabrera
(2)
Miguel Gomez
(1)
Miguel Tejada
(5)
Mike Fontenot
(3)
Mike Ivie
(1)
Mike Kickham
(9)
Mike Leake
(11)
Mike Matheny
(1)
Mike Morse
(10)
Mike Yastrzemski
(1)
Mike Yazstremski
(2)
milestone
(1)
minor league
(1)
minor league contract
(4)
minors
(11)
mismanagement
(1)
misnomer
(1)
mistakes
(2)
MLB
(2)
MLB stupidity
(2)
MLB Success
(7)
MLB Trade Rumors
(1)
MLBAM
(1)
MLBTR
(1)
MLE
(1)
Mock Draft analysis
(8)
Modern Portfolio Theory
(1)
Modus Operandi
(2)
MPT
(1)
MVP
(2)
Natanael Javier
(1)
Nate Schierholtz
(45)
Nathanael Javier
(1)
Nationals
(1)
Naysayers
(2)
Negotiations
(1)
Neil Ramirez
(1)
NewPQS
(8)
Next Gen
(1)
Nick Hundley
(2)
Nick Noonan
(27)
Nick Pereira
(1)
Nick Vander Tuig
(2)
Nick Vincent
(1)
NL Champions
(2)
NL Playoffs
(1)
NL West
(29)
NL West Division Title
(20)
NL West Future
(1)
NLCS
(22)
NLCS MVP
(2)
NLDS
(8)
Noah Lowry
(14)
non-roster invitees
(2)
non-tenders
(3)
Nori Aoki
(4)
NPB
(1)
NRI
(1)
Oakland A's
(4)
OBP
(1)
oddities
(1)
Offense
(4)
offensive era
(1)
ogcPQS
(6)
Omar Vizquel
(3)
one-run games
(3)
Opener
(1)
openers
(1)
Opening Day
(6)
opening day pitcher
(3)
opening day roster
(11)
Optimism
(1)
Osiris Matos
(2)
Outfield
(3)
outfielder curse
(1)
overturned
(1)
Ownership
(7)
Pablo Sandoval
(97)
Padres
(1)
Panda
(6)
Pandoval
(1)
passing
(1)
Pat Burrell
(15)
Pat Misch
(5)
Patrick Bailey
(2)
Payroll
(11)
PECOTA
(1)
Pedro Feliz
(12)
PEDS
(10)
Perfect Game
(2)
perjury trial
(1)
personal
(2)
Personal Reminiscence
(2)
Pessimism
(1)
Pete Palmer
(1)
Pete Putila
(1)
Pete Rose
(3)
Peter Magowan
(2)
Phil Bickford
(3)
Phillies
(7)
philosophy
(1)
Phoenix Theory of Rebuilding
(1)
Pierce Johnson
(2)
Pitch Count
(3)
pitch framing
(1)
pitch value
(1)
Pitcher hitting 8th
(1)
pitcher’s health
(1)
Pitchers League
(1)
Pitching
(27)
pitching analysis
(4)
pitching department
(1)
pitching development
(4)
Pitching Rotation
(90)
pitching staff
(6)
pitching strategy
(2)
plate discipline
(1)
platoon players
(2)
Play Ball
(1)
player acquisition
(1)
player budget
(2)
player development
(8)
playoff
(2)
playoff analysis
(6)
playoff competitiveness
(1)
playoff hopes
(39)
playoff roster
(2)
playoff rotation
(6)
Playoff Success
(29)
Playoff Win Effective
(3)
Playoff Win Efficient
(2)
Playoffs
(44)
postmortem
(2)
PQS
(109)
press conference
(2)
pressure
(2)
priorities
(1)
Projected Record
(6)
projection
(2)
projections
(2)
promotion
(2)
prospect
(4)
prospect analysis
(7)
prospect future
(2)
prospect handling
(1)
Prospect of Note
(3)
prospect promotion
(1)
prospect study
(3)
Prospects
(46)
quality starts
(1)
questions
(1)
radio great
(1)
Rafael Rodriquez
(8)
Rajai Davis
(2)
Ralph Barbieri
(1)
Ramon Ramirez
(3)
Randy Johnson
(10)
Randy Messenger
(2)
Randy Winn
(14)
Rangers
(5)
Ranking
(4)
rant
(1)
raspberry
(1)
rationalization
(1)
Ray Durham
(5)
Rayner Arias
(1)
re-sign
(2)
realist
(1)
Rebuilding
(5)
Rebuilding Myths series
(1)
rebuttal
(1)
Red Sox
(1)
Reds
(5)
Reggie Crawford
(1)
rehab
(1)
reliever
(3)
relievers
(1)
Relocation Concession
(2)
Research
(2)
resource scarcity
(1)
rest for starters
(1)
Retired
(3)
Retirement
(3)
return
(1)
Reyes Moronta
(3)
RHP
(1)
Ricardo Genoves
(1)
Rich Aurilia
(7)
Rick Peterson
(1)
Rickie Weeks
(1)
Ricky Oropesa
(3)
right-handed
(1)
risk mitigation
(2)
risk profile
(1)
Roberto Gomez
(1)
Rockies
(2)
Rod Beck
(1)
Roger Kieschnick
(13)
Roger Metzger
(1)
Ron Shandler
(2)
Ron Wotus
(1)
Ronnie Jebavy
(1)
Ronnie Ray
(1)
rookie debut
(1)
Rookie of the Year
(1)
Roster
(4)
rosterbation
(2)
Rotation by Committee
(1)
Rotation Chaos
(1)
ROY
(2)
Royals
(3)
Rule 5
(2)
Rule 5 Draft Pick
(5)
rumors
(9)
run differential
(1)
run prevention
(1)
run production
(1)
runs support
(1)
Russ Ortiz
(11)
Russell Carleton
(1)
Ryan Garko
(2)
Ryan Klesko
(4)
Ryan Rohlinger
(2)
Ryan Theriot
(3)
Ryan Vogelsong
(93)
Ryder Jones
(2)
Sabean Naysayers
(7)
Sabermetric Thoughts
(6)
sabermetrics
(5)
SABR
(1)
Salary speculation
(3)
SALLY
(1)
Sam Dyson
(7)
Sam Long
(1)
Sam Selman
(1)
Sam Wolff
(1)
San Jose Giants
(1)
San Jose Relocation
(3)
Sandro Fabian
(2)
Sandy Rosario
(1)
Santiago Casilla
(9)
scenarios
(1)
Scott Boras
(1)
Scott Harris
(2)
Scott McClain
(2)
Scott Shuman
(1)
Scouting
(2)
Sean Hjelle
(5)
season review
(1)
secret sauce
(2)
Sergio Romo
(17)
Seth Corry
(6)
SF Giants
(2)
Shilo McCall
(1)
Shohei Ohtani
(3)
Shohei Otani
(2)
Shooter
(1)
shutouts
(1)
Signature Song
(1)
signing
(13)
Silly-Ball
(3)
South Atlantic League
(1)
South Bay Rights
(1)
SP usage
(1)
spin rate
(1)
splits
(2)
Sports Illustrated
(1)
Spring Training
(16)
stabilized stats
(1)
standings
(1)
starting CF
(1)
starting lineup
(19)
starting pitching
(96)
starting rotation
(5)
StatCast
(2)
Statcorner
(1)
State of the Giants
(1)
statistics
(2)
STATS
(1)
Steamer
(1)
Stephen Vogt
(1)
Steroids
(7)
Steve Edlefsen
(4)
Steve Johnson
(3)
Steve Okert
(8)
Steven Duggar
(7)
strikeout rate
(2)
Sue Burns
(1)
sunk costs
(1)
superstition
(1)
tactics
(1)
talent evaluation
(4)
Tax
(1)
team culture
(1)
Team of the 2010's
(2)
Team of the 2020's
(1)
Team of the Decade
(4)
Team Speed
(1)
Team Support
(1)
Thank You
(2)
The Evil Ones (tm)
(1)
The Giants Way
(2)
The Hardball Times
(1)
The Hey Series
(19)
The Hey Zaidi Series
(4)
Thomas Joseph
(3)
Thomas Neal
(9)
Tigers
(4)
Tim Alderson
(17)
Tim Hudson
(39)
Tim Lincecum
(195)
TINSTAAPP
(1)
Todd Linden
(3)
Todd Wellemeyer
(6)
Tommy Joseph
(3)
Tony Watson
(4)
Top 100 Prospects
(1)
Top 14 Roster
(1)
Top Draft Position
(4)
top Giants prospects
(6)
top player list
(1)
top prospect list
(6)
Trade
(12)
Trade Analysis
(22)
Trade Idea
(9)
Trade PTBNL
(2)
Trade Rumors
(30)
trading
(1)
training staff
(2)
Training Tool
(1)
transitional season
(1)
Travis Blackley
(1)
Travis Ishikawa
(47)
Trevor Brown
(5)
Trevor Gott
(1)
tribute
(1)
Tristan Beck
(2)
turning point
(1)
Ty Blach
(23)
Tyler Austin
(1)
Tyler Beede
(10)
Tyler Cyr
(1)
Tyler Horan
(1)
Tyler McDonald
(1)
Tyler Rogers
(2)
Tyler Walker
(2)
umpire mistake
(3)
Umpires
(3)
USA Today
(1)
utility
(1)
Voros McCracken
(1)
Waiver Roulette
(1)
Waldis Joaquin
(5)
walks
(1)
Wall of Fame
(1)
WAR
(4)
Warrior Spirit
(1)
Wendell Fairley
(10)
What-If Scenario
(3)
wild card
(1)
wild card race
(1)
Will Bednar
(1)
Will Clark
(1)
Will Smith
(7)
Will Wilson
(3)
Williams Jerez
(1)
Willie Mac Award
(1)
Willie Mays
(1)
winning on the road
(1)
Winter League
(1)
winter meetings
(3)
World Series
(28)
World Series Champions
(13)
WS Ring Bling
(1)
xBABIP
(1)
xwOBA
(1)
Yankees
(1)
Yusmeiro Petit
(40)
Zack Cozart
(2)
Zack Minasian
(2)
Zack Wheeler
(9)
Zaidi Haters
(1)
Zaidi MO
(2)
Zaidi Rotation
(3)
ZiPS
(1)
Zito Role
(2)
Oftentimes the low-profile moves have the most impact. Some players previously touted by their organizations that have now fallen out of favor are Mat Gamel, Kelly Johnson, and JJ Hardy.
ReplyDeleteDo you see any of these players as good fits for the Giants long-term?
If so, could any be had without giving up JSanch or solid prospects? My hypothetical is some combination of Velez, Bowker, Schierholtz, Sosa, Tanner, etc.
Crawford plays on the Rays, Riccardi worked for the Jays.
ReplyDeleteThe list of "big name free agents" sure looks like something to avoid. As in, run screaming.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if Sabean has the smarts to get a good "out of favor" guy.
Gamel is not going anywhere, so you can forget about him. The Brewers have already stated they're not trading him.
ReplyDeleteThe Brewers sent Hardy to the minors for a period this season to delay his arbitration qualification. The sole purpose here was to increase his trade value to other teams. He's probably available, but I suspect the asking price will be too high.
Kelly Johnson is an interesting player who is "out of favor." He has some defensive deficiencies, but he may not command a high price tag. Realistically, the choice would be between him and FSanchez. We all know that Sabean is not going to admit his Alderson mistake, so FSanchez is coming back....make bank on it. Therefore, Kelly Johnson is not needed.
BJ Upton is a player widely rumored to be "out of favor." The Rays are going to want real players for him. I suspect that JSanchez may not be enough for them. Upton has a lot of talent and is young. Would love to see him on the Giants patrolling CF instead of Rowand.
Velez, Bowker, Schierholtz, etc. are not going to bring back real players back to the Giants in a trad scenario. Think about it for a minute......they're not good enough to play regularly for one of the worst offenses in baseball. Why would another team want one of them?
I realize that those three (with the possible exception of Bowker) are mediocre. I simply wanted to gauge their talent levels relative to these 3-4 players.
ReplyDeleteIf anything at all good can be found in exchange for several pieces of the logjam of mediocrity, Sabean should jump on it.
But on the other hand, Sabean thinks Velez is a leadoff hitter; hopefully he's lying through his teeth as a ploy to raise trade value, because Velez has none of the on-base or base-stealing skills necessary to be more than a replacement-level (i.e. bad) leadoff hitter.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDoesn't it just warm your heart that all these young, high-upside players are available now and we traded the perfect exchange chips away a couple of months ago for an beat-up aging player and an average 1B just hitting arbitration whose value is sapped by his horrible defense?
ReplyDeleteI'm on board with the idea of getting JJ Hardy and signing Beltre to play third. we can move pablo to 1st and renteria to 2nd. I don't think it's a good idea to bring Franchez back...What about trading for one of minnesota's extra OF? Span, Young, Cuddyer, Gomez, Kubel?
ReplyDeletedregarx, where did you get the idea that either Barnes or Alderson were "high-upside" players? Don't believe the fanboy hype.
ReplyDeleteBoth Barnes and Alderson looked to be nice middle of rotation guys, and that was before the season. Alderson pretty much blew that up with his performance last season, and Barnes, while he pitched nicely in San Jose, that's still a long way to the majors and pitchers with stats like his in Advanced A are not automatic for the majors, let alone "high upside".
You can't just read the pre-season rankings and still think that applies at the end of the season. Plus, for most teams, beyond their top 4, the vast majority never do more than a peep in the majors. It is just a nature of the beast. There was a good post by El Lefty Malo (check him out) about BP's Kevin Goldstein's statement that out of any farm system, any year, maybe 2 will become starters and 2 some sort of bench player/reliever (but my memory is bad sometimes, so go there and search for Goldstein). The tough part is that those 4 are not always your top 4, many fail to make the leap from good in AA or AAA to just making the majors.
I like both trades in terms of value we got in return, but I didn't like either trade in terms of helping out the Giants in 2009's playoff chase. I think those trades might have cost us a few wins, because Ishikawa was out while Garko struggled and Franchez was injured. If we have both for 2010, I think we will be improved if Franchez is healthy and if Garko is platooned with Ishikawa at 1B.
Garko's hitting isn't sapped by his defense, though its certainly reduced. His defense in 2008, according to Fielding Bible was just very slightly negative in runs.
Anon, I agree with Boof that getting JJ Hardy will be expensive to do, I think I saw their GM say that they are not available, so we would have to overpay.
ReplyDeleteIf Renteria is healthy - IF - then I'm OK with him at SS, he would be valuable then.
I'm OK with Franchez if we sign him to a deal like he offered to the Pirates, 3 years at $20M, but not at $8M next year.
I like the Twins extra OF, we reportedly was offered Gomez for Sanchez by the Mets a few years back - good thing Sabean knew what he got - but I don't know what they will want in return, Frandsen or Rohlinger plus a pitching prospect is about all I would go for, otherwise I think we would be overpaying.
You misread me.
ReplyDeleteIt would be possible to trade them for high-upside players, like Hardy/Johnson/Gamel. I'm not calling them high-upside themselves.
Look, now that we don't have them as trade chips, there's a huge gap in trade value between a Bumgarner/Posey and a Tanner/Sosa. You have to admit that takes a big bite out of our trading options; our MiLB 'pitching depth' is reputation more than reality after this season.
You need to think the FSanchez trade through further.
ReplyDelete1) Could the Giants trade Sanchez now for a comparable prospect to Alderson? The information (end-of-year shoulder surgery) known now to all was known to both parties at the time of the trade. The current trade value of Sanchez, though, is far below that of Alderson, and that difference is extremely large compared to the production Sanchez gave us this season.
2) The Pirates under Neal Huntington are undergoing full rebuild. If Huntington had been unable to trade Sanchez, he was not going to exercise the option, as evidenced by the contract offer with $/yr lower than the option in an All-Star season.
3) You are "OK with Franchez if we sign him to a deal like he offered to the Pirates, 3 years at $20M, but not at $8M next year." There's the admission that Sanchez is not worth the value of the option. You would only accept the retention of Sanchez under a newly negotiated contract.
4) Such a negotiated contract will nearly duplicate any contract that would have been negotiated with Sanchez in free agency had the trade never occurred; the option provides a small amount of leverage in that we can use it to keep control of him if negotiations break down, but at an undesirable price. If that price is so undesirable that we refuse to exercise the option, we will be at the exact same position that we would have been without trading Alderson.
Thus, the marginal gain in losing Alderson is this season’s production plus the essentially nonexistent leverage of the option in the negotiation of a future contract.
That marginal cost is multiples greater than the marginal gain. This trade is awe-inspiring in its one-sidedness.
The Garko trade was acceptable.
ReplyDeleteOK, understood about the high-value.
ReplyDeleteLet's take your premise that we don't trade Alderson to the Pirates for Franchez. Soon we will have a 21 year pitcher who can barely strike out anyone at AA. Yes, he's younger, but at a sub-5 K/9 rate, he's going to take at least a couple of years to figure out how to strike out batters at this level unless he has an epiphany this season (unlikely).
That would make him a 23 year old in AAA still struggling to strike out batters. Then a 24-25 year old at the MLB level.
His main value was as a very young pitcher ready to pitch soon in the majors, but that is no longer looking to be a strong possibility.
Even with that, his top end value was only as a middle-rotation starter, but that is looking very suspect now too.
In other words, he's not trade bait for high-value players, he is trade bait for another performance-challenged prospect, like an Andy Marte, or an old player that you need for only a year.
Meanwhile, even if we sign Franchez to the $8M contract for 2010, if the trainers are right and he's healthy, at worse we can trade him away mid-season for a prospect or two, who are worth more than Alderson would be.
FYI, 3 years at $20M is not market value, it was a discounted value that he offered Pittsburgh. He's above average at 2B when healthy, considering offense and defense.
But that does not mean that a team will necessarily do that this off-season, with the bad economy and everything. It can go either way, he could get a really good contract but if the economy is still hurting, then he might get nothing. And some people will accept the bird in the hand versus the bird in the bush, and not go free agent.
With his injury history, he sees what happened to a similar player to him in Orlando Hudson (but not as good a hitter), it would behoove him to negotiate now with the Giants and get a long-term contract, because Sabean's history is to move on if things don't work out, and he could end up with a one year contract around what Hudson got, late in the off-season.
If any of the NY teams, or Boston, or LA really wanted him, he could easily get 3 years at much over $20M, but if the market is cold, he could end up with another one year contract. Same with another team, I'm not sure who is looking. But that doesn't mean he will necessarily get 3 years at $20M.
And even if we keep him, and not trade him, then we should be able to get a draft pick or two for him, depending on how he does in 2010, and his overall ranking/rating.
I think we got good value for a quickly declining prospect. $8M for Franchez would be OK, but I think we can get him to sign a discounted multi-year deal because of the bad economy and the leverage of the bird in the hand versus two in the bush. We would not necessarily have signed him to 3 years at $20M if there is another bidder, that is a risk there for the Giants in letting him go. There is a risk for him to walk away from us that he might get something like Hudson. Both sides limit their risk by negotiating now and getting it done.
Alderson's value is pretty much blown away, particularly after his poor showing with Pittsburgh's AA club. Luckily, Pittsburgh needs all the middle rotation guys they can get, they can't even get them, let alone ace of staff caliber like Lincecum, Cain, Sanchez, Bumgarner, maybe Wheeler.
So I would posit that it is awe-inspiring in what the GIANTS got for what we gave up. Not quite a Jason Schmidt level steal, but if Sanchez is healthy (that was an issue with Schmidt too, BTW), then we got a great deal, value now instead of 3-5 years from now.
Um, yeah.
ReplyDeleteOur net return was essentially ZERO; we are negotiating with Sanchez with a situation in which he is basically a free agent.
In a parallel situation without a trade, we could have negotiated with any number of free agent middle infielders, including Sanchez, and gotten a player with the same worth/$.
You are trying to tell me that this is OK, because Alderson has gotten so bad that 'TradeValueAlderson'=0.
Look at the worst-case scenario for Alderson. In two years (2011), he enters a rotation and provides 5-starter production. Three years of a back-of-the-rotation starter at club-controlled cost: that is an asset of value, whether or not his potential to be a No. 2 has been blown away.
So we lost that. And we gained next to nothing. This trade is easy to analyze.
"we got a great deal, value now instead of 3-5 years from now"
ReplyDeleteWe both know that Alderson will be a major leaguer in 1-3 years so don't pretend it's a possibility he'll make his debut as a 25-year old.
I hope you realize the disconnect between your belief in the rebuilding status of the Giants (I concur with you on this subject) and your assertion that it is "a great deal" to get value "now" as opposed to "[1-3] years from now".